Back to Wheel of Books
Cover of A Lancaster County Christmas

A Lancaster County Christmas

by Suzanne Woods Fisher

Fiction ChristmasAmishChristian FictionChristianAmish FictionRomance

Book Description

Amidst the snow-dusted charm of Lancaster County, a Christmas season brims with secrets and heartache. When a young woman stumbles into a tangled web of old grudges and new hopes, the warmth of community is tested like never before. As relationships deepen and tensions flare, the true spirit of the holiday hangs in the balance. Will the magic of the season bring healing, or will buried resentments destroy everything they hold dear? In a world where faith and family collide, can love really conquer all?

Quick Summary

In "A Lancaster County Christmas," Suzanne Woods Fisher weaves a poignant tale set in the heart of Amish country. The story follows two couples—Solomon and Mattie Riehl, an Amish pair facing a heartbreaking struggle with infertility, and Jaime and C.J. Fitzpatrick, an English couple reeling from the challenges of family loss and marital disconnect. When a snowstorm unexpectedly brings their worlds together under one roof, old wounds and personal secrets rise to the surface. Through the lens of faith, forgiveness, and the serene backdrop of Lancaster’s winter, each character is tested by heartache and hope. Ultimately, the novel explores whether healing and reconciliation are possible, illuminating the meaning of Christmas in the bonds we share and the grace we extend.

Summary of Key Ideas

Healing Through Community

Set in the tranquil yet vibrant Amish settlement of Lancaster County, the story centers around Mattie Riehl, whose quiet joy with her husband Solomon is shadowed by their inability to have more children. As Christmas approaches, Mattie’s sorrow deepens, but she finds comfort in the steadfastness of her faith and the warmth of her close-knit community. Meanwhile, the Amish way of life itself is painted as both haven and crucible—where personal struggles are supported and sometimes magnified by the bonds of family and neighbors.

Faith Amid Trials

The arrival of Jaime Fitzpatrick, a non-Amish woman struggling with her own familial loss and emotional detachment from her husband C.J., disrupts the gentle rhythm of the Riehls’ world. A winter storm strands Jaime and C.J. at the Riehl farm, forcing both couples to confront their pain and misunderstandings in close quarters. The juxtaposition between Amish tradition and "English" modernity becomes a narrative catalyst for introspection and change, challenging characters to open their hearts and minds.

Power of Forgiveness

As old grievances surface—unspoken anger, unresolved grief, and marital strain—the characters grapple with the meaning of forgiveness. In Jaime’s reluctance to reconcile with her husband and Mattie’s struggle to trust God’s plan, Fisher explores the difficult but redemptive path to healing. The process is neither easy nor instantaneous, depicted with emotional authenticity as characters wrestle with disappointment, doubt, and fragility.

Complexities of Family Relationships

Threads of hope run through the story, spun from faith and the small, steadfast acts of kindness exchanged between the protagonists. The warmth of Christmas traditions—simple meals, heartfelt prayers, and shared work—serves as a backdrop for gradual transformation. Through these rituals, the wounded begin to glimpse possibilities for renewal, reminded that compassion and honesty can mend the deepest of hurts.

Rediscovering the Spirit of Christmas

By Christmas Eve, the tangled web of secrets and resentments has been acknowledged and begins to unravel. The season’s message of grace emerges powerfully, as the foursome learns to accept both human limitation and divine providence. In the chilly quiet of a Lancaster winter, New Year hopes flicker to life, affirming the promise that family, faith, and forgiveness can bring new beginnings, even in the midst of loss.